|
Editorial: Steve Smith Comments on Nichia's Recent White LED Related Patent Statement
... Nichia Corporation of Anan, Japan, along with the other major white LED manufacturers, Toyoda Gosei, Osram Opto, Cree and Lumileds make up what the community regards as "The Big 5" and have all entered into some kind of cross-licensing arrangement with Nichia some time back, which seemed to put...
Jump down to the full story
| |
Features:
|
|
Japan Getting Pro-Active to Prevent Patent OutflowApril 11, 2004...Since we're beginning to hear more about patent litigation issues once again,
especially as they related to the blue spectrum LEDs, it's interesting to see
that more Japanese firms in general, and outside that sector, are resorting
to suits to do what they can to "stem the technology drain" that appears
to be currently underway. That's the theme of an article
which appeared in the Nihon Keizai Shimbun April 7 morning edition. In
it, the reporters track lawsuits filed recently by Fujitsu Ltd. against South
Korea's Samsung SDI Co. alleging patent infringement on technology for plasma
display panels, but what's happening isn't exclusive to PDPs, as you can see
by our editorial,
this issue, where patent attorney Steve Smith comments on Nichia's recent white
LED related patent statement. The indications, says the Japanese news source,
is that Japanese firms are increasingly invoking patent rights to prevent the
outflow of their state-of-the-art technologies.
A follow-up article was posted on April
8th morning edition titled Japan Firms Strengthen Resolve to Tackle Infringement.
Thus, it looks like other Japanese companies are ready to enter legal battles
to protect their patents. Behind their toughening stance are the rapid technological
innovations being achieved by South Korean and Taiwanese rivals, in this case,
Samsung Electronics Co. of South Korea. SEC became the largest shareholder in
the global DRAM market about a decade after entering the arena in 1983. It grabbed
the top position in the global thin-film-transistor liquid crystal display market
six to seven years after moving into the market in 1995, according to Nihon
Keizai Shimbun April 8 morning edition, where it was also reported that,
in addition to Fujitsu's suit against Samsung, the actions of the companies
involved are expected to have a major impact on the global PDP market, which
is projected to expand to 1 trillion yen in three to four years. So far, neither
firm has shown any willingness to seek an out-of-court settlement.
What? RFMD Worry?April 11, 2004...If you wonder if our industry takes a hit when one of the major wireless phone
makers predicts lowered expectation (most recently, Nokia), just take a look
and see what RF Micro Devices is seeing. On April 6th and 8th, RFMD of Greensboro,
North Carolina USA seemed to think things are going pretty well. Consistent
with their webcast to financial followers on March 9th, RFMD still anticipates
their Q-1 revenue will be at the high end of the range of approximately $152
million to $163 million. We'll know more when RFMD and their competitors report
quarterly earnings throughout April. RFMD also reported that the reason they're
doing well, is that they've Increased shipments to Samsung Electronics, which
is currently the #3 cellphone major, behind Motorola and Nokia, and evidently
making it known they intend to move up in the rankings asap.
RFMD is shipping high-volumes of their RF3146 third-generation PowerStar
power amplifier (PA) module to Samsung Electronics. RFMD supplies PowerStar
PAs into approximately 70 percent of Samsung's GPRS handsets. Based on existing
design wins across more than 30 GPRS handsets, RFMD expects to increase its
GSM/GPRS PA market share at Samsung this year. Additionally, the Company anticipates
incremental revenue opportunities at Samsung in 2004 in cellular transceivers
and in CDMA power amplifiers. Joe Grzyb, general manager of power amplifier
products at RF Micro Devices, said, "We are pleased to extend our relationship
with Samsung to include our RF3146 PowerStar power amplifier modules. Samsung
is a global leader in cellular handsets, and we look forward to supplying additional
PA components in their future generations of handsets." Details are on the
RFMD news release.
Spectrolab's Solar Cells Score Space Tech Hall of FameApril 11, 2004...Yes, there is a "Hall of Fame" for companies working in space technology, and Boeing's
Spectrolab unit was recently inducted into it for their high efficiency multijunction
solar cell work. It's called the Space Technology Hall of Fame, which is sponsored
by the U.S. Space Foundation, and the distinction was bestowed upon Spectrolab
at the National Space Symposium. Four Spectrolab associates – Bruce T. Cavicchi,
James Ermer, Dr. Nasser H. Karam and Dr. Richard R. King– were honored at the
recent Space Technology Hall of Fame dinner in Colorado Springs, Colorado USA.
Also honored were representatives of the USA's Air Force Research Laboratory
(AFRL) for sponsoring research and development in this particular, and critical
technology area. Spectrolab is a wholly owned subsidiary of Boeing Satellite
Systems and considered a leading manufacturer of space-qualified multijunction
solar cells and panels. Their latest solar cells now in production, called the
Ultra Triple Junction cells, feature Spectrolab’s third-generation triple
junction design that convert more than 28 percent of the sunlight reaching them
into electricity.
“This award is a fitting and well deserved tribute to the Spectrolab team.
Spectrolab solar cells and panels have provided reliable power for many decades
to all our satellite models, and have enabled satellite power growth across
the industry in recent years,” said David Ryan, vice president and general
manager of Boeing Satellite Systems. Also at the awards, Dr. David Lillington,
president of Spectrolab, praised his colleagues for dedication to continuous
improvement in the quality, reliability and performance of space solar panels.
He also thanked the Air Force for supporting Spectrolab’s efforts to develop
this technology. Spectrolab triple junction solar cells are currently powering
numerous commercial and government satellites, including Galaxy IIIC, a Boeing
702 satellite that is one of the world’s most powerful satellites ever launched
into space. Company
news release
Intel Leads the Way Getting the Lead OutApril 11, 2004...Environmental activism within the semiconductor industry is always good news,
and at the recent Intel Developers Forum in Tokyo, Japan, Intel let it be known
that all should follow their lead when it comes to literally "getting the
lead out." At the Forum, Intel Corporation announced it will begin eliminating
an impressive 95% of the lead used in its processors and chipsets starting later
this year and they specifically noted that they're taking these significant
steps to remove lead from its product packaging in order to make it more environmentally
friendly. The company shipped its first lead-free memory chips last year and
said it will begin shipping the lead-free technology with select microprocessors
and chipsets in Q3, 2004, and embedded IA processors in Q2, 2004. Furthermore,
additional Intel products will be transitioned as manufacturers become able
to handle them.
The new Intel packages use lead-free solder balls, about the size of salt crystals,
and represent the majority of lead used in Intel microprocessor packaging. Intel
is working with the industry to find a reliable solution for the tiny amount
of lead still needed inside the processor packaging to connect the actual silicon
"core" to the package. The transition to lead-free is a massive industry-wide
effort with many technological, logistical and economic challenges. Since 2000,
Intel has been working with industry consortia and the European Union's Restriction
of Hazardous Substances (RoHS) legislation committee to come up with a solution
that can be used around the world. Helpful details for those who need to learn
more about how to also reduce the lead in their products can be found in the
Intel company
news release.
Anadigics Introduces New One Watt InGaP HBT Power AmpApril 11, 2004...Anadigics Inc. of Warren, New Jersey USA has expanded its line of wireless
infrastructure products with the introduction of a one watt InGaP
HBT amplifier which addresses medium power basestation applications by providing
adjacent channel power rejection (ACPR) of greater than 70 dBc, while meeting
the demanding reliability requirements of the wireless infrastructure market.
The new product is called the ADR3410 and was designed in cooperation with a
leading cellular basestation equipment manufacturer and optimized the amplifier
to deliver high performance for a WCDMA signal over the wireless frequency bands
of 850 to 2200 MHz. "This new one watt amplifier is the first in a new family
of products at ANADIGICS that expands our served available market in wireless
infrastructure by serving the requirements of medium power basestation applications,"
said Ron Michels, VP of Broadband Products at Anadigics. "We developed the
ADR3410 to answer our customers requirements for greater performance at higher
output power and the feedback we received verifies that we have introduced a
market leading product. Building on our growing portfolio of best of breed InGaP
HBT amplifiers, this product delivers the performance and reliability desired
by wireless network carriers to enable enhanced 3G services." The ADR3410
is priced at $5.05 in quantities of 1,000 units. Samples are available. Company
news release Our news features are reported
by the CompoundSemi News staff writers.
For submissions or content suggestions, you can contact us using
editor -at - compoundsemi.com
For more information and to reserve promotion space contact
Info7 -at - compoundsemi.com
or call +1 (512) 257-9888 |
|
The
McDonald Report
Commentary & Perspective...
April 11, 2004...Nichia Corporation of Anan, Japan, along with the other major white LED manufacturers,
Toyoda Gosei, Osram Opto, Cree and Lumileds make up what the community regards
as "The Big 5" and have all entered into some kind of cross-licensing
arrangement with Nichia some time back, which seemed to put an end to the white
LED patent disputes. Now that the build up beyond "The Big 5"
is increasing at a dramatic rate (as evidence by the interest in our Blue
2004 event to be held in Taiwan May 10-12), the issue of blue spectrum patents
is coming back into the news.
A statement
was posted recently on Nichia's website regarding their white LED patent position
within the international blue spectrum device community. In it, Nichia called
special attention to the fact that "certain LED manufacturers in South
Korea, Taiwan and other countries have obtained from Osram patent license to
manufacture white LED's by combining LED's with fluorescent substances."
Nichia underscored that, with regard to white LED's, they hold valid and enforceable
patents in many countries beyond Japan and cautioned manufacturers in South
Korea and Taiwan, specifically, that any license granted under Osram patents
does not necessarily equate to a license under Nichia's patents. The statement
went on to say that "those who manufacture, import, use and/or sell
white LED's using such fluorescent substances or any products incorporating
such white LED's are strongly warned to pay close and unremitting attention
not to cause any infringement upon those basic patents held by Nichia."
We consulted our resident (and favorite) USA patent expert, Attorney Stephen
C. Smith, of Brinks Hofer Gilson &
Lione in Chicago, Illinois and asked his opinion of what this statement
means in relationship to the overall international blue spectrum LED community.
Steve knows the field of compound semiconductor technology from all levels,
having 20 years of coming through the ranks as a LED, laser, and epitaxy technology
expert EE, which included a long stint with Emcore prior to becoming a patent
attorney. Steve's interpretation of Nichia's statement is, as follows:
"They may have patented portions of the product that are necessary for
the florescence. Parts of the total product are patented by some inventors,
whereas other portions of the product are patented by others. Nichia is saying
that they are going to enforce their patents on that particular part of the
product, and from the language they appear serious. Only time will tell. However,
I am sure they will listen to any reasonable offer for a license. The key is...
What do they consider as reasonable? This is where cross-licensing becomes
important. The manufacturers are basically saying 'you can use my patents to
make your product if I can use yours to make my product.' That's why it is so
important for the big guys to build a patent portfolio. Those patents
become bargaining chips when infringement is asserted. With the explosion of
Blue in Asia, it would appear that they are worried about China. I would be
surprised if we did not see more Japanese-USA cooperation over time. It will
be interesting to say the least."
Steve Smith will be a routine guest columnist in this slot on CompoundSemi
News. Should you want to contact Steve Smith directly, visit his bio
(and picture) on the BrinksHofer.com website or email him directly at
ssmith@brinkshofer.com. And should
you want to contact Nichia on questions relating to their patent position, the
contact name at the end of the statement
is Masayuki Kinoshita in Business Planning at Nichia Corporation Tel: +81-884-22-2311.
Japan, China and South Korea Teaming on Emerging TechnologiesApril 11, 2004...According to a recent AP wire report titled Asians
Team Up on Emerging Technologies filed by Yuri Kageyama in Japan, the governments
in Japan, China and South Korea are teaming to develop new technologies, including
fourth-generation mobile phones, digital broadcasting, computer security and
open-source software. Talks have evidently been underway over the last several
months to work out ways to cooperate on projects like the 2008 Beijing Olympics
and next gen Internet. The latest meeting was in Seoul in March "where
they agreed to share information and work together on developing fourth-generation
mobile phones by 2010." The article
goes into considerable detail on 4G phones and open source software for those
who follow the wireless sector. If you have questions about the
solid state lighting and compound semiconductor industries or have news
or views to share, I'm Jo Ann McDonald, Editor of LIGHTimes and CompoundSemi News.
Feel free to contact me directly, anytime. 
My direct tel at the ranch is
+1-325-463-5345
From time to time Jo Ann may comment on companies in which she holds a
modest investment - be sure to read
her disclosure at some point in time... |